Listen to this article (47:37 min)
Philosophers Series Column
This article was published exclusively online in the Christian Research Journal Volume 49, Number 04 (2026).
When you support the Christian Research Journal, you become a vital partner and help provide the resources at equip.org that minister to people worldwide. These resources include our ever-growing database of thousands of articles and Bible Answers, as well as our free Postmodern Realities podcast and our free audio article podcast, Christian Research Journal Reads.
You can also support our online articles by leaving a tip. A tip is just a small amount, like $3, $5, or $10 (the price of a coffee or lunch out). To leave a tip, click here.
SYNOPSIS
Modernity is synonymous with progress and hope for the future. It is also full of suffering, alienation, and contradictions that have driven skeptical prophets to question the Enlightenment’s grand narrative. Marx and Freud explored our modern misery by grappling with the differing priorities of human instinct and human civilization, of the community and the individual. Herbert Marcuse (1898–1979), a German-Jewish intellectual of the Frankfurt School, synthesized their ideas into his own leftist critique of capitalism and the status quo. Driven by the question of why the revolution failed — why the working class remained content with their chains despite Marxist predictions — Marcuse speculated that capitalist systems use “surplus repression” (labor above and beyond necessity) and the “performance principle” (personal pride in productivity) to manipulate us into happily accepting our own exploitation. These methods of control whittle down our inner lives through technology and consumer culture until we become “one-dimensional” people incapable of imagining alternatives.
Marcuse’s diagnoses have merit even though his proffered solutions are equal parts pretentious abstraction and illiberal coercion. His faith in intellectual elites to liberate the masses from their “false consciousness” and “false needs,” combined with his endorsement of “repressive tolerance” (a one-way censorship of the Right by the Left), reveals an authoritarian impulse lurking beneath his libertarian rhetoric about sexual and personal liberation.
By examining Marcuse’s life, his key ideas about civilization and repression, and his deep-rooted fear of fascism, we can trace his pernicious influence on the contemporary problem of political violence. His skepticism toward systems of power and his warnings about human susceptibility to manipulation deserve our serious attention, but we must resist his contempt of ordinary people, and his doubt in their capacity for judgment and honest disagreement. Through the cultivation of deep reading, intellectual humility, and the democratic virtue of loving others personally even as we disagree with them propositionally, we can prove Marcuse’s pessimism wrong.
MAKING THINGS BETTER MAKES THEM WORSE?
Since the Enlightenment, the West has insisted on a linear narrative of progress. The past was bad; the present is good; the future will be even better. There’s plenty we can point to to bolster this optimism: scientific discoveries, technological innovation, a rising standard of living, widespread literacy, the advent of civil rights. The United States was born out of this hopeful, forward-facing attitude towards the growth of freedom and the rights of the individual to pursue happiness.
But the West has also produced its own prophets skeptical of liberal-democratic capitalist society. Karl Marx (1818–1883) and Sigmund Freud (1856–1939) pointed to the shadow side of human nature and social institutions that couldn’t be erased by “progress.” In the era of industrialization, Marx analyzed the misery and exploitation of poor and working-class people whose lives were uprooted from the self-determination of rural subsistence and local community and thrown into the maw of urban factories and slums. In the era of Victorian fustiness, Freud psychoanalyzed the distress and dysfunction of his bourgeois patients whose repressed instincts leaked out sideways into a host of self-destructive pathologies.
Marx speculated that primordial human communities were sites of cooperation rather than competition, an original unity shattered by capitalistic exploitation. Freud’s genesis myth speculated the opposite, that societal structures were born as a response to patriarchal domination, sexual monopoly, rebellion, and remorse. Whether the advance of civilization is a corruptor of human nature (because our instincts are good) or a check on human nature’s corruption (because our instincts are bad), Marx and Freud saw the contradictions of modern society. They grappled with the question of how the individual and the community ought to reconcile their differing priorities, and what we ought to do about the peculiar forms of misery that advanced industrial societies create.1 Whether people should rise up and revolt together in hope for a better world or lie down alone on the analyst’s couch in resignation to the world we’re stuck with — something must be done.
Exploitation, alienation, repression, guilt, powerlessness, uprootedness, meaninglessness — a society that is deeply inhumane for both the haves and the have-nots — these wounds lie at the heart of Marxist and Freudian critiques of modernity. One need not agree with Marx and Freud to concede that their writings name a problem — that the very endeavor to expand our civilizational and technological reach, for the sake of increasing our freedom and happiness, can lead (paradoxically) to the experience of bondage, dehumanization, estrangement, anxiety, and despair. Every “solution” we come up with generates a new set of problems to solve. Our efforts to make things better are costly: we always succeed in making some things worse. The very concept of “progress” is rife with contradiction.
Herbert Marcuse (pronounced mahr-KOO-zuh)2 was the modern philosopher who attempted to synthesize the controversial and contradictory claims of Marx and Freud about modern man. He became known as a founding father of America’s New Left in the 1960s counterculture by articulating his own version of how the world’s gone wrong and how we ought to live. Like Marx,3 Marcuse believed that the task of philosophy was not merely to interpret the world, but to change it.4 Marcuse was surprisingly (and sadly) successful in this: his greatest legacy today lies in America’s escalating crisis of political violence and our increasing willingness to condone it.
HERBERT MARCUSE’S HISTORY
Herbert Marcuse (1898–1979) was born in Berlin to upper-middle-class German-Jewish parents. He was drafted into the army halfway through World War I but was never sent to the front. At eighteen he was cleaning horse stables for the military while attending lectures at the University of Berlin. He briefly participated in the 1918 German Revolution as a member of a soldier’s council but was disappointed by the hesitancy and passivity of the other young men. While the German Revolution got rid of the monarchy and instituted a parliamentary democracy, it did not achieve the radical socialist transformation the communists and other revolutionaries hoped for. Marcuse’s brief political activism in his youth led him to study Marx’s writings, as he sought to understand why the revolution petered out after its partial success. He wrote:
I became more and more politicized during this period [by 1919]. It was evident that fascism was coming, and that led me to an intensive study of Marx and Hegel. Freud came somewhat later. All this I did with the aim of understanding just why, at a time when authentic conditions for revolution were present, the revolution had collapsed or been defeated, the old forces had come back to power and the whole business was beginning all over again in degenerate form.5
After his early foray into politics ended in disappointment and confusion, Marcuse turned to the academy. His interests spanned multiple disciplines, including philosophy, literature, art, economics, and politics. He earned a doctorate in German literature in 1922 and studied with Martin Heidegger (1889–1976) while preparing a postdoctoral dissertation — Hegel’s Ontology and the Theory of Historicity (1932). From the work of G. W. F. Hegel (1770–1831) he learned the value of “negative philosophy,” which is essentially critical: “It refuses to accept what now exists as the mark of the genuinely real. It is a protest against the status quo and demands something higher, better, more beautiful, rational, and freer than the ‘given.’”6
Marcuse took this Hegelian idealism with him when, in 1933, he became a member of the Frankfurt-based Institute for Social Research, commonly called the Frankfurt School. Rather ironically, the Institute was funded by the independently wealthy Marxist scholar Felix Weil, whose capitalist father made his millions as a grain trader. The first generation of the Frankfurt School — Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, Walter Benjamin, and Herbert Marcuse — developed what came to be called Critical Theory, combining Marxism with studies in Freudian psychology, sociology, philosophy, history, and linguistics, expanding orthodox Marxist theory beyond economic determinism.
The critical social theorists were deeply opposed to both fascism and capitalism, and sought to understand why those most oppressed within the current system not only failed to free themselves through revolutionary action but seemed content with their chains, a problem widely acknowledged as “the crisis of Marxism.”7 The Frankfurt School produced politically committed scholarship that sought not only to critique society but to support its transformation by helping to liberate people from the systems that dominated them, seeking “to protect, preserve, and, where possible, extend the limited and ephemeral freedom of the individual in the face of the growing threat to it.”8
Marcuse viewed the alliance between Germany’s affluent upper class and the Nazis as not merely a historically particular power play to gain the upper hand against the working class and the communists in a time of upheaval; he believed the connection between capitalism and fascism was not incidental but rather causal and systemic, that “Nazism represented a culminating stage in the development of a bourgeois society based on a capitalist economy, such that in the philosophy and theory of Nazism one found the culmination of tendencies present throughout the bourgeois epoch.”9 Put bluntly, Marcuse was convinced that capitalism creates Nazis.
When the Nazis came to power in 1933, the Jewish Marcuse could see the writing on the wall: he moved to the Frankfurt School’s branch in Geneva, Switzerland. The following year he immigrated to the United States to continue his work with the Institute in its relocation to Columbia University. Marcuse became a naturalized U.S. citizen in 1940, and published Reason and Revolution: Hegel and the Rise of Modern Social Theory in 1941.10 During World War II, he worked in the Office of War Information creating anti-Nazi propaganda and later served as a senior intelligence analyst on Germany to the Office of Strategic Services (predecessor to the CIA). As the war ended, he became chief of the Central European section for the Office of Intelligence Research. Marcuse’s work with the U.S. government was motivated by his deeply held antifascist beliefs, which continued to permeate his writings even as he returned to academia in 1951.11 Marcuse taught at Columbia, Harvard, and Brandeis, eventually settling at the University of California, San Diego in 1965, where he remained until his retirement in 1976.12
EROS AND CIVILIZATION
During the 1950s and 1960s, Marcuse wrote his most well-known works that appealed especially to college students coming of age during the Vietnam War. Many an undergrad carried his books in their backpack and used his theories as fuel for student protests. In Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud (1955), Marcuse turned to Freud to supply the social psychology that Marxism lacks. He addressed the question of why the working class doesn’t liberate themselves from capitalist oppression. In Marcuse’s mind, if the expected revolution failed to occur, it can’t be that Marxism is a false theory: it must be that working class consciousness has been manipulated to make people act against their own interests.
Marcuse opens Eros and Civilization by reminding his readers of Freud’s insight “that civilization is based on the permanent subjugation of the human instincts” in a process he dubbed “repression.”13 “Happiness must be subordinated to the discipline of work as full-time occupation, to the discipline of monogamic reproduction, to the established system of law and order,” Marcuse says in summary of Freud. “The methodical sacrifice of libido, its rigidly enforced deflection to socially useful activities and expressions, is culture.”14 In other words, Freud believed a free and stable society required personal repression, the sublimation of sexual instincts into marital monogamy, childbearing, and socially beneficial work.15 This is civilized society at the cost of individual happiness and unfettered sexual gratification. Freud thought civilization was worth the price of its psychological discontents — worth it, and inevitable.16 In the clash between the id-driven “pleasure principle” and the ego-driven “reality principle,” reality wins, society thrives, and miserable people with deep pockets get psychotherapy to cope with it.
Freud thus pitted freedom and happiness against each other, a tragic attitude likewise held by Marx, who understood that the freedom to choose includes the freedom to choose badly. Marcuse, however, treated freedom and happiness as two sides of the same coin, insisting that we are not truly free unless we are also happy. In Eros and Civilization, Marcuse coined his own Freudian-sounding terms to modify — to the point of contradiction — Freud’s original pessimistic meaning in favor of a utopian attitude: the dream of a “non-repressive civilization”17 that gives free rein to libido rather than bullying it into submission for the greater good.
Marcuse proposed the twin concepts of “surplus repression” and “the performance principle” to give Freudianism a positive twist.18 While he acknowledged that a basic level of repression is necessary for civilization because of material scarcity and the self-restraint required to overcome it through labor, Marcuse saw this scarcity as a solved problem. The incredible productivity of industrial society has eliminated the need for the nine-to-five, he thought. The fact that we tolerate the daily grind, that we still organize our lives around 40+ hour work weeks — even though we have collectively solved the problem of scarce resources through our technological prowess — shows that we are suffering from societally imposed surplus repression that benefits a dominant group at the expense of everyone else.
Marcuse argued that the need for full-time work is not a feature of the reality principle, an unavoidable fact of life. After all, pre-industrial, pre-capitalist societies had other ways of organizing the work required for subsistence: universal wage labor and the selling of one’s labor on the open market in competition with others was a contingent rather than an inevitable historical development. As Marcuse liked to point out, it could have been otherwise (and thus could still be otherwise).19 The modern capitalist rat race isn’t the culmination of “progress” or our destiny: it’s a particular form of social domination controlling us in the name of reality and under the guise of necessity — repressing us beyond what is required to meet our basic needs for food, clothing, shelter, and security.
Marcuse asserted that this enervating surplus repression is socially reinforced through the performance principle — a secularized version of the Protestant work ethic in which a few lucky people may find identity, purpose, and deep satisfaction in their work, while the majority labor in alienation and unfreedom. Marcuse argued that “the bulk of the work relations on which civilization rests is of a very different kind” from the dream of the fulfilling career, and “satisfaction in daily work is only a rare privilege.”20 He wrote, “The work that created and enlarged the material basis of civilization was chiefly labor, alienated labor, painful and miserable — and it still is. The performance of such work hardly gratifies individual needs and inclinations. It was imposed upon man by brute necessity and brute force.”21 Moreover, “Men do not live their own lives but perform pre-established functions….Libido is diverted for socially useful performances in which the individual works for himself only insofar as he works for the apparatus, engaged in activities that mostly do not coincide with his own faculties and desires.”22
The sadistic genius of the repression we face, Marcuse believed, is in the way that all of us, both the bourgeoisie and the working class, internalize the performance principle and make it a feature of our own consciousness and conscience. We become not only content with our chains, but proud of them. We relish our productivity and efficiency; we take pride in the length of our to-do lists; we answer every well-meaning “How are you?” with “Busy!” and engage in what Marcuse called “the resentful defamation of rest, indulgence, and receptivity”23 — attitudes that reveal our allergy to a moral framework that includes something like a Sabbath. Marcuse wrote:
The restrictions imposed upon the libido appear as the more rational, the more universal they become, the more they permeate the whole of society. They operate on the individual as external objective laws and as an internalized force: the societal authority is absorbed into the “conscience” and into the unconscious of the individual and works as his own desire, morality, and fulfillment….The individual lives his repression “freely” as his own life: he desires what he is supposed to desire; his gratifications are profitable to him and to others; he is reasonably and often even exuberantly happy. This happiness, which takes place part-time during the few hours of leisure…enables him to continue his performance, which in turn perpetuates his labor and that of the others.24
The performance principle which we’ve all internalized denies us the time, energy, happiness, and freedom we ought to enjoy, and that we could enjoy, if only society’s material abundance was shared and equitably distributed so that everyone had enough.25 This is how Marcuse’s neo-Freudianism leads him back to Marx’s socialism: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!”26 Precisely how this equitable distribution of resources is supposed to be implemented is never spelled out.
Marcuse’s critique of the capitalist system of control will have a ring of truth to anyone who has suffered through a miserable dead-end job they couldn’t afford to quit; to anyone who has stitched together a patchwork of minimum wage and gig work while still being unable to pay the bills; to anyone who has gone deeply into debt for a degree in a field that suddenly became obsolete because of “progress”; and to anyone has endured the anxiety of being let go through no fault of their own and set adrift on the open sea of unemployment, seeking the next job like a shipwreck survivor flailing desperately for driftwood. Marcuse’s purported solutions and alternatives to the current order are too abstract and absurd to be taken seriously, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that he rightly names a problem: our economic arrangement turns work and profit into an idol that couldn’t care less about individual freedom and happiness. The Bottom Line is a cruel master.
Even so, Marcuse’s “theology of work” remains fundamentally flawed, and not merely because he favors Marxist redistribution (which is unimaginable without coercion). It’s flawed for reasons more banal than economic theory: Marcuse is an elitist snob. He is so smitten with his own line of intellectual work (to read, write, think, and teach) and its close cousin of aesthetic work (the arts), that he sees manual labor and run-of-the-mill tasks as beneath human dignity, inherently alienating, and worthy of nothing but being automated out of existence. While Marcuse waxes poetical about “the free play of human faculties,”27 the fulfillment of genuine human needs, and the possibility of “a new basic experience of being” beyond the reality principle,28 the fact remains that he lacks respect for people who earn their bread by the sweat of their brow:
No matter how justly and rationally the material production may be organized, it can never be a realm of freedom and gratification; but it can release time and energy for the free play of human faculties outside the realm of alienated labor. The more complete the alienation of labor, the greater the potential of freedom: total automation would be the optimum. It is the sphere outside labor which defines freedom and fulfillment, and it is the definition of the human existence in terms of this sphere which constitutes the negation of the performance principle….The lamentation about the degrading effect of “total work,” the exhortation to appreciate the good and beautiful things in this world and in the world hereafter, is itself repressive in so far as it reconciles man with the work world which it leaves untouched.29
Marcuse is right to criticize the idolization of paid work as a core human value and source of identity. He is right to lambaste the performance principle as the means by which a dominant class with overwhelming economic power convinces people to devote the lion’s share of their energies to a corporation which owes them nothing and will cut or replace them in a hot minute if doing so will boost the bottom line. But he is wrong to think that physical labor in and of itself is degrading and alienating; he is wrong to think that people who find a sense of belonging through coworker camaraderie, who feel proud of being practically useful to their community, and who find satisfaction in a job well done (even if that job is mundane or automatable) are mere dupes of corporate America suffering from “false consciousness.”30
For someone supposedly on the side of the working class, Marcuse has a funny way of showing it. Perhaps he was counting on his writing style being inscrutable to the people he was ostensibly helping, so that his contempt would remain hidden behind his rhetorical abstractions, what his critics call “bluff and bombastic prose,”31 “pretentious nostrums” in “inflated language which induces excitement rather than thought.”32 One can only imagine how Marcuse might feel today about the prospect of AI replacing countless jobs: so many workers are on the cusp of “liberation,” about to discover the “free play of their faculties”! Little did he know that our technology would not only eat up blue-collar livelihoods but would even come for white-collar careers — including those like Marcuse who work with words for a living.
The irony comes thick and fast: Marcuse speculated about what later radicals called “Fully Automated Luxury Communism,”33 the dream of being liberated from labor in a post-scarcity society of technologically supplied abundance. Today, however, it isn’t Marxists carrying the torch of tech-fueled liberation, but rather uber-capitalists and tech bros — they are the ones selling us the vision of a post-work AI utopia, where Universal Basic Income (UBI) frees all the truck drivers and administrative assistants to take up painting and haiku. (He fails to mention what all the professional painters and poets will do with their newly found free time. Long road trips? Home filing systems?)34 As expected, the post-scarcity distribution details remain frustratingly fuzzy: “We’ve got to make sure it gets distributed fairly, but that’s more of a political question,” admits Demis Hassibis, CEO of Google DeepMind. “That’s going to be one of the biggest things we’re gonna have to figure out.”35 Indeed. No one is any clearer now about the magical transformation of late-stage capitalism into abundant socialist sharing than Marx was when he first thought of it. The devil is in the details of distribution.36
SEXUAL LIBERATION
Despite its occasional insights, Eros and Civilization comes up short because of its utopian and elitist presumptions that remain out of touch with real life and regular people. It likewise fails because of Marcuse’s equivocal use of the terms “libido” and “eros” to refer not only to instinctual life energy which the daily grind drains out of us, but also to refer to explicit sexual desire. Marcuse’s call to “resist oppression” — when that oppression is capitalist and corporate — is at least somewhat relatable and has its place in the Christian tradition, especially in Catholic social teaching on the dignity and rights of workers (see Rerum Novarum, 1891, and now Magnifica Humanitas, 2026).37 But when eros and libido are understood literally as the human sex drive, the oppressive/repressive forces are no longer The Man or The Bottom Line, but marriage and family life. Happily married couples might be surprised to find that the intimacy and fidelity they enjoy is smeared as “monogamic genital supremacy” by Marcuse.38 Marriage, with its taboos on sexual union outside of the bond, is merely a holdover from a bygone era of scarcity that is now a component of the “irrational apparatus of repression,” he thought.39 To seek to maintain that intimacy and fidelity in marriage, while raising a family, is to unwittingly support the social domination of the capitalistic status quo. To be truly liberated from economic and social domination, one must also be sexually liberated.
“Since Marcuse sees the channeling of sexual libido into genital and monogamic channels as part of the process of surplus repression,” philosopher and critic Alisdair MacIntyre writes, “he consistently sees at least some of the taboos imposed on forms of sexuality taken to be perverse as part of the irrational apparatus of repression.”40 To cast off surplus repression of libido doesn’t just mean championing the cause of the two-day work week: it means intentionally engaging in non-procreative, promiscuous sexual behaviors that privilege personal pleasure alone, giving the metaphorical middle finger to romantic marital sex.
Like Freud, Marcuse believed human sexuality is first polymorphously perverse before it is anything else, being rooted in the bodily pleasure-seeking and allegedly incestuous fantasies of infancy and childhood41 — an error I have criticized before (see my article on “Sigmund Freud and the Making of Our Modern Sexual Identity”).42 In Freud’s framework, repression is necessary to shape this nascent perversity into something compatible with civilization. Freud never dreamed of calling for sexual liberation because he knew that breaking our sexual taboos would be civilizational suicide.
But Marcuse’s innovation of the concept of surplus repression enables him to have his cake and eat it too. He imagines we could “desublimate” the sex drive while keeping intact all the nice and orderly parts of society founded on duty and self-restraint.43 True to form, Marcuse is heavy on abstractions and light on details. MacIntyre again: “It is impossible to avoid asking Marcuse, as he picks his way through allusions to coprophilia and nervously glances at sadism: “What will we actually do in this sexually liberated state?”44 Marcuse — apparently still too repressed to get into specifics — left it to the hippies, the swingers, the free-love flower children, and the gay rights movement to take the hint, which they most assuredly did. Critical theorist Douglas Kellner writes in praise of Marcuse: “In an uncanny way, the text [Eros and Civilization], with its emphasis on polymorphic sexual liberation, play, cultivation of an aesthetic ethos, and burning desire for another world and way of life, anticipated the counterculture of the 1960s which lived out many of the key ideas in Marcuse’s visionary text.”45 The New Left was delighted to have an activist professor on its side, lending intellectual credibility to the practice of promiscuity. The only thing better than sleeping around is being convinced that a sordid sex life is actually an expression of one’s highest political ideals.
ONE-DIMENSIONAL MAN
Marcuse’s masterwork is One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society (1964) — the book he is most known for and the way most people first encounter him. Marcuse attempts to break through his readers’ casual assumption of being free people. “A comfortable, smooth, reasonable, democratic unfreedom prevails in advanced industrial civilization, a token of technical progress,” he writes on page one.46 Advanced technology, as the child of the Scientific Revolution and industrial capitalism, is man’s project to experience, transform, and organize nature as “the mere stuff of domination.”47 The trouble is, man himself is also a part of nature: dominating nature inevitably includes dominating people. That’s why Marcuse views technology and its supposed liberating potential with deep skepticism, placing him in good company alongside technology critics like Lewis Mumford, Jacques Ellul, Hannah Arendt, Marshal McCluhan, and Ivan Illich.48 Marcuse writes, “Technology serves to institute new, more effective, and more pleasant forms of social control and social cohesion….In the face of the totalitarian features of this society, the traditional notion of the “neutrality” of technology can no longer be maintained….In the medium of technology, culture, politics, and the economy merge into an omnipresent system which swallows up or repulses all alternatives.”49 Indeed, “‘Totalitarian’ is not only a terroristic political coordination of society, but also a non-terroristic economic-technical coordination which operates through the manipulation of needs by vested interests. It thus precludes the emergence of an effective opposition against the whole.”50
In an all-consuming technologically saturated society, it becomes almost impossible to imagine living otherwise. We become flattened and simplified, Marcuse argues, emptied out of our individuality and private inner worlds (the space where we may become and remain ourselves apart from public opinion and behavior). “Today this private space has been invaded and whittled down by technological reality,”51 Marcuse laments. This is not just a personal loss but also a political one, for that rich, inner dimension of the mind is the place where opposition to the status quo can take root. The ability to be genuinely critical of The Way Things Are; the ability to imagine an alternative that is “higher, better, more beautiful, rational, and freer than the ‘given’”;52 the ability to perceive the ways one is being manipulated technologically, economically, politically, and psychologically by the powers that be — this is what it means to be a two-dimensional man. Such people have inner depth, self-awareness, moral imagination, and genuine agency to act according to conscience. Marcuse deeply feared that the capacity for “negative thinking,” to imagine possibilities and create alternatives beyond what currently exists, was being obliterated in affluent societies.
Marcuse wrote about this whittling down of the inner life in the age of 1960s television, at a time when many people still read for pleasure (a practice that sustains and deepens this two-dimensionality). His critique of technology has only grown in scope and applicability since the introduction of the internet and social media, along with the smart phone which makes such “connectedness” inescapable (does anyone go to the bathroom or to bed without phone-in-hand anymore?). Marcuse’s judgment is all the more apt since our rates of reading have plummeted.53 Solitude, “the very condition which sustained the individual against and beyond his society,” is now virtually impossible because of our technological saturation.54 So much of our mental space has been colonized by an omnipresent system run by the vested interests of surveillance capitalism which not only monitors but “tunes, herds, and conditions” our behavior for the sake of others’ profit.55 With such ubiquitous and continuous conditioning, how can we trust our own assessment of our needs?
Advertising not only generates false needs within us which consumerism prompts us to fulfill, creating a specious form of happiness; we are also lulled into a false sense of freedom, as if the choice between Crest and Colgate, Verizon and T-Mobile, Fox and MSNBC, Republican and Democrat, was actually an indicator of democratic liberty (as long as you have options, aren’t you free?). Even the apparent competition between political alternatives takes place within definite boundaries of acceptability. The ethos of bohemian, punk, or LGBTQ subcultures, which appear to be repudiating the system, are in fact granted a place within the system to play-act at protest and let off steam (notice the irony/oddity of corporations celebrating Pride Month and displaying Pride flags). Even art — which Marcuse saw as a bastion of necessary cultural criticism and a generator of alternative ways of seeing and being in the world — has been so popularized and dumbed down that it has been de-fanged. Art no longer has a bite but is domesticated by the process of commodification.
Alisdair MacIntyre sums up Marcuse’s effort to turn what ought to be good news (people’s needs are being satisfied in modern industrial society and we appear to have plenty of choices) into bad news after all:
The fundamental thesis of One-Dimensional Man is that the technology of advanced industrial societies has enabled them to eliminate conflict by assimilating all those who in earlier forms of social order provided either voices or forces of dissent. Technology does this partly by creating affluence. Freedom from material want, which Marx and Marcuse himself took and take to be the precondition of other freedoms, has been transformed into an agency for producing servitude. When men’s needs are satisfied, their reasons for dissent and protest are removed and they become the passive instruments of the dominating system.56
Measured Christian Agreement. There are aspects of Marcuse’s critique which Christians can immediately resonate with and reinterpret on our own terms: we deceive ourselves about what we need; we easily become passive and pleasure-seeking; we are lulled into cultural conformity; we are nudged more by algorithms than by the Holy Spirit; we imagine we are free when in fact we are slaves to our own desires; we have forfeited a rich inner life of intellectual independence and become mouthpieces for tribalistic political opinions that have nothing to do with the Gospel. The call to “not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” is as true for us now in modern industrial society as it was when St. Paul wrote it (Romans 12:2 ESV).
Marcuse’s critique of overarching systems of domination and oppression that trap people in ways of living that are soul-crushing and inhumane is something that Christians have been articulating for ages — we just have different names for it. We speak in terms of human sin and the Fall (Genesis 3), or the contrast between the city of Man and the city of God (Augustine), or the rulers, the authorities, the cosmic powers over this present darkness, and the spiritual forces of evil against which we wrestle (Ephesians 6:12). Marcuse blames capitalism and technology for most (if not all) of our woes; there’s room for argument on that point, but at least we can agree with him that things are not as they should be, and that human aspirations and decisions often make things worse.
We can grant Marcuse the power of his criticism without accepting his proposed solutions. Underneath his pseudo-religious critique of “the system” is his elitism, which shows itself most clearly in his discussion of what exactly we’re supposed to do about the problem of “false needs”57 and “false consciousness.” Marcuse asserts that only individuals who are truly free are able to be the final arbiters of what their true needs are. But in this current comfortable totalitarianism of consumer capitalism, the vast majority of people are not actually free. That means someone must tell the “sheeple” what’s best for them since they can’t discern it for themselves. That someone is Marcuse, of course, along with his enlightened progressive followers. His very style of writing conveys his conviction that readers are there to be catechized, not convinced. He never bothers to present facts and construct arguments in an effort to persuade: he simply asserts The Truth in abstract propositional form — with absolute, unquestionable authority — as if he can’t conceive that a skeptical reader would require that he show his receipts.
Like Marx, Marcuse divides people into two groups: those who are molded by their circumstances (the majority), and those who mold others (an elite minority).58 Marcuse, somehow having escaped the totalizing indoctrination to which the rest of us are prone, calls his motley band of misfits (“the substratum of the outcasts and outsiders, the exploited and persecuted of other races and other colors, the unemployed and unemployable”) to engage in revolutionary protest against the capitalist-fascist elites who currently wield control.59 The working class and regular folks are no longer deemed worthy or capable of freeing themselves. The fight for the future of humanity will take place instead between battling elites: those with the money and technical power who support the status quo (and condition the masses to accept it), and those armed with critical theory, negative thinking, and intellectual chops — those smart enough to save the poor brainwashed (and now smartphone-addled) plebs.
REPRESSIVE TOLERANCE
Framing the cultural and political fight on these terms leads directly to a discussion of Marcuse’s most famous essay, “Repressive Tolerance” (1965), in which he argues not only that tolerance of dissenting opinions within modern democratic societies is a farce, but that support for a truly impartial and “content neutral” freedom of speech is morally catastrophic. Marcuse’s skepticism is surprising: most of us are raised to see free speech and the practice of tolerating those with whom we disagree as acts of faith in human rationality and the principle of non-violence. Freedom of speech is for people who are humble enough to know that they could be wrong, and hopeful enough in our ability to learn from each other — through public argument and mutual tolerance — that we reach a closer approximation to the truth while accommodating our inevitable differences. These hallmarks of democracy not only presuppose a baseline of civic and personal virtue, but also of literacy and the cool-headed, analytical capacity that literacy fosters (in contrast to intense emotional appeals). Free speech, tolerance, and public civility are classical liberalism’s alternatives to centuries of European religious war and bloodshed over dogma. We collectively decided to use words instead of weapons, to convince others rhetorically instead of killing them physically. That decision was an act of faith in human reason and conscience.
To Marcuse, however, the time-honored traditions of tolerance and free speech exist in name only today, because they presume an equal playing field between opposing sides that he believes doesn’t exist. Minority views — and in the context of the 1950s and 1960s he means left-wing views — are permitted expression only because they are so drowned out by the majority conservative status quo that it is impossible for them to effectively persuade and mobilize political opposition. As Alisdair MacIntyre puts it, “The majority are effectively controlled by the system and so molded that they cannot hear or understand radical criticism. It follows that the people have no voice and the alternatives are not between genuine democracy and the rule of an elite, but between rival elites, the repressive elite of the present and the liberating elite of the Marcusean future.”60
Marcuse has little faith in the average person’s ability and willingness to listen, think, deliberate, weigh alternatives, exercise rational judgment, or change his or her mind in the face of new facts. Having described how deftly modern industrial society and mass media manipulate people and keep them from exercising their reason and freedom, Marcuse basically gives up on us. Individual human agency and rationality aren’t salvageable for regular Joes:
The democratic argument implies a necessary condition, namely that the people must be capable of deliberating and choosing on the basis of knowledge, that they must have access to authentic information, and that, on this basis, their evaluation must be the result of autonomous thought….Under the rule of monopolistic media — themselves the mere instruments of economic and political power — a mentality is created for which right and wrong, true and false are predefined….Rational persuasion, persuasion to the opposite is all but precluded.61
We cannot be equipped to think and then trusted to judge, he implies; we can be saved only by our intellectual betters and the “outsiders” and “outcasts” they have enlisted as foot soldiers in the culture war. At least Marx believed men had to liberate themselves; Marcuse, on the other hand, paints the masses as passive objects of re-education efforts by a chosen few who know better, a “dictatorship by minority” (a Stalinist position).62 With such presuppositions, it becomes clear that the best Marcusean strategy would be to catch and indoctrinate young minds, to infiltrate the education system, because convincing adults to change their minds is a hopeless and pointless endeavor. Critical social theorists don’t want (or don’t believe in) independent thinkers: they want true believers.
As noted earlier, Marcuse worked with the American government to create anti-Nazi propaganda during World War II. His view of fascism was that it took advantage of the liberal values of free speech and tolerance to indoctrinate the German masses who lacked the moral discernment to reject it. By gaining a platform on the world stage in a “free exchange of ideas,” Hitler and his microphone dragged the world into war and the Jews into Auschwitz. That is what a total commitment to free speech looks like, Marcuse believed — a violent abuse of the concept of tolerance in which morally intolerable words and actions are allowed to take root in susceptible minds. These are the stakes of “false consciousness” when it is engendered by a demagogue’s free speech and then publicly tolerated, given time to do its damage.
This is why Marcuse speculated that “if democratic tolerance had been withdrawn when the future leaders started their campaign, mankind would have had a chance of avoiding Auschwitz and a World War. The whole post-fascist period is one of clear and present danger” that “requires the withdrawal of tolerance before the deed, at the stage of communication in word, print, and picture. Such extreme suspension of the right of free speech and free assembly is indeed justified only if the whole of society is in extreme danger.”63 Having fled the Nazis and then fought them in print, Marcuse saw Nazis around every (capitalistic) corner. He felt justified in calling progressives to practice “discriminating tolerance in an inverse direction” to shift the balance of power from the Right to the Left by restraining the liberty of conservatives, thus “strengthening the oppressed against the oppressors.”64
Marcuse doesn’t argue that whichever side is the minority in the grand scheme of things has the right to censor the majority by whatever means necessary: his thesis in “Repressive Tolerance” isn’t content neutral. He says explicitly that the Left is permitted and encouraged to censor the Right, and that the Left will always be the beleaguered minority because that is simply the nature of the Left. He apparently couldn’t imagine our current state of affairs, in which the mainstream media, though solidly conservative in his day, is now reliably left-leaning, and that in universities (especially the Ivy Leagues) progressive faculty and students vastly outnumber conservatives. Marcuse’s political tribe won the culture war of the 1960s and then became ensconced in some of the most powerful public institutions we have. The irony is that many on the Left continue to act as if they were still a beleaguered minority who is justified in being intolerant so they can keep fighting The Man. The Left cannot see that now it is The Man.
For the past decade, Marcusean “liberating elites” (today dubbed the “woke”) have engaged in anti-free speech, intolerant strategies that are lifted directly from Marcuse’s pessimistic playbook: shutting down public speaking events, dis-inviting speakers from university campuses, employing the heckler’s veto to drown out speakers so the audience cannot hear them, issuing threats, cancelling and doxxing people with “hateful” views, and even perpetrating acts of violence.65 Anti-fascist groups like Antifa have attacked and bloodied independent journalists,66 and continue to engage in violence and disorder causing major injuries, deaths, and widespread property damage to this day.67 In 2025, an assassin fired a bullet with the engraving “Hey Fascist! CATCH!” at the controversial conservative free speech advocate Charlie Kirk,68 murdering him in the midst of his public attempt to argue ideas with the Left in a civil manner.69 Read New York Times writer Roxanne Gay’s cynical response to Kirk’s murder (“Civility Is a Fantasy”) to see Marcuse’s “Repressive Tolerance” alive and well in progressives’ self-understanding:
The people who call for civility harbor the belief that we can contend with challenging ideas, and we can be open to changing our minds and we can be well mannered even in the face of significant differences. For such an atmosphere to exist, we would have to forget everything that makes us who we are. We would have to believe, despite so much evidence to the contrary, that the world is a fair and just place. And we would have to have nothing at stake….Calling for civility is about exerting power. It is a way of reminding the powerless that they exist at the will of those in power and should act accordingly. It is a demand for control.70
Marcuse expected the Left to treat those who are (in their view) Nazis, or on the cusp of becoming so, with anticipatory, pro-active censorship. How often have you heard people engage in this Marcusean-flavored thought experiment: If you could go back in time and kill Hitler before he took control of Germany, would you do it? Wouldn’t it be justified? How then ought we to treat the “proto-Hitlers” of today? According to a recent survey of college students by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), the Right has grown weary of playing the civility game with an opponent who refuses to follow liberalism’s rules, and is increasingly embracing intolerance and even violence against those who hold opposing views.71 FIRE Chief Research Advisor Sean Stevens says that, “More students than ever think violence and chaos are acceptable alternatives to peaceful protest. This finding cuts across partisan lines. It is not a liberal or conservative problem — it’s an American problem. Students see speech that they oppose as threatening, and their overblown response contributes to a volatile political climate.”72
PROVING MARCUSE WRONG
This new acceptance of political violence is one of the rotten fruits of Marcuse’s “Repressive Tolerance,” along with his moral pessimism and his now widely shared inability to metabolize the fact that people of goodwill and intelligence can have genuine disagreements that aren’t a result of oppressive power-plays, false consciousness, or indoctrination. For all of Marcuse’s talk of the necessity of imagination, he fails to imagine the possibility that he could be wrong, that he might have something to learn from regular working-class people and their priorities, and that conservatism might have something meaningful to contribute that isn’t contaminated with fascism. It’s uncharitable to blame him for having trouble letting go of his deep dread of a Nazi comeback. But we can blame him for providing today’s “woke” critical social justice movement — and now its “woke Right”73 mirror image that adopts the same vibes and tactics — with an intellectual-sounding veneer that justifies political dogmatism, coercion, and violence. Start with the rules apply to thee and not to me, and before long we’re in the situation of there are no rules, simply raw power.
Upon discovering Marcuse’s writings and seeing the throughline to today’s troubles, it’s tempting to focus our attention on progressives’ illiberalism and take pleasure in listing out their transgressions. A better response would be to adopt a measure of Marcuse’s skepticism towards “the system” and become aware of our own moral malleability. We can put that heightened awareness to use by rehabilitating our own capacity for deep thought and personal freedom. There is plenty in Marcuse’s writings that can trigger self-examination and repentance rather than demonization of the other side. One-Dimensional Man made me deeply ashamed of how captured my attention is by the endless lure of content on my smartphone, and freshly aware of how much I am distracted and molded by forces that monetize my attention. Eros and Civilization convicted me of the falseness of finding my identity in my work, in taking undue pride in my productivity, and in my utter failure to practice Sabbath rest. “Repressive Tolerance” shed light on how tempting it is for me to view those with whom I disagree not as thoughtful people with a point, but as brainwashed dupes, incapable of rational judgment, unworthy of being given a hearing because their words sound like memes, not arguments. But how sure am I that my thoughts are genuinely my own and not merely Internet imports? And have I truly rejected Marcuse if I cast aside his revolutionary ideas but unconsciously adopt his elitist posture? There’s more than one way to be a Marcusean.
The time I’ve spent reading Marcuse and his critics has confirmed for me the irreplaceable value of deep reading — including reading people with whom I disagree. If it’s true that widespread literacy is the foundation of liberal democracy, and if it’s likewise true that our culture is fast becoming post-literate, then the political turmoil, tribalism, and informational confusion we are seeing now is only the beginning of our fall from faith in human rationality.74 More than anything, I feel a drive to prove Marcuse wrong, to be a regular Joe who reads and a hard worker who rests; to be a “two-dimensional” person capable of critical and imaginative thought; to be able to keep my head under the pressure of consumer conditioning and to change my mind when rationally persuaded; to befriend my neighbors regardless of political, religious, racial, and economic differences; to be a free woman and a faithfully married mother at the same time; to be a non-leftist without being a fascist. If I can develop rational convictions that are tempered by humility (I could be wrong) and love (people are more important than ideas), that doesn’t mean Marcuse would be wrong about everything, but at least he’d be wrong about me.
A taste for disagreement is a virtue in a Western liberal democracy. Fearing disagreement — hating it, even — is a vice. We will always face the temptation to collapse the tension of disagreement through coercion (censorship and violence) or withdrawal (estrangement and going “no contact”) — fight-or-flight strategies which reveal our impatience, cowardice, arrogance, fragility, and lack of imagination. The only way the shared experiment of America continues is if we can disagree with others propositionally while still loving them dispositionally. In one of his homilies last year, Pope Leo XIV said, “No one is called to dominate; all are called to serve. No one should impose his or her own ideas; we must all listen to one another. No one is excluded; we are all called to participate. No one possesses the whole truth; we must all humbly seek it and seek it together.”75 Granted, he was talking about the Church, whose supreme rule is love, and this is not the same domain as politics. But the principles of non-dominance and humility still hold whenever a group comes together to make collective decisions and take collective action. We have to learn how to live with each other without having convinced each other. On a small scale, this is simply the practice of being a family.76 Family life, with all of its arguments, irritations, and compromises, is the training ground for the democratic, pluralistic virtue of getting over yourself and getting along (anyone who is driven crazy by a relative they love knows what I mean).
This virtue has Thanksgiving Dinner as its sacrament, when we gather around a shared table instead of around a shared ideology — when we break bread together simply because we belong to one another in this time and place and circumstance, and not because we share the same beliefs. We learn to cherish one another in the flesh without insisting on seeing inside each other’s heads and without nitpicking over one another’s words. We do not have to agree on everything (even on extremely important things!). But we do have to pass the potatoes. I’m grateful to Marcuse for reminding me of the difference.77
Alisa Ruddell is a staff writer and associate editor for the online magazine Christ and Pop Culture and has previously published at Front Porch Republic, Salt and Iron, and the Christian Research Journal.
NOTES
- Andrew Feenberg, “Marcuse’s Concept of Eros,” talk delivered at the Marxism and Psychoanalysis conference, Simon Fraser University, 2018, accessed October 10, 2026, https://www.sfu.ca/~andrewf/Marcuse%27s%20Concept.pdf.
- Harold Marcuse, “Herbert Marcuse Official Homepage,” Herbert Marcuse, accessed November 12, 2026, https://www.marcuse.org/herbert/index.html.
- Karl Marx, “Theses on Feuerbach,” in Marx/Engels Selected Works, vol. 1 (Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1969), 15.
- Richard T. Bernstein, “Herbert Marcuse: An Immanent Critique,” Social Theory and Practice 1, no. 4 (Fall 1971): 99, accessed October 10, 2026, https://www.jstor.org/stable/23556661.
- Herbert Marcuse, quoted in Bradley G. Green, What Is Critical Theory?: A Concise Christian Analysis (Crossway, 2026), 10, https://static.crossway.org/excerpts/media/21befa2793b025b43cbbb3e6e9841509f224ea44/What_is_Critical_Theory__Excerpt.pdf.
- Bernstein, “Herbert Marcuse: An Immanent Critique,” 97.
- Green, What Is Critical Theory?, 10–13.
- Max Horkheimer, “Preface,” in Critical Theory: Selected Essays, trans. Matthew J. O’Connell et al. (Herder and Herder, 1972), viii.
- Alasdair C. MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic (Viking Press, 1970), 6.
- Richard Wolin, “Herbert Marcuse,” Encyclopaedia Britannica, accessed October 11, 2026, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Herbert-Marcuse.
- Roger D. McGrath, “The Man Who Made Cultural Marxism,” Chronicles: A Magazine for American Renewal, May 2024, accessed October 11, 2026, https://chroniclesmagazine.org/columns/sins-of-omission/the-man-who-made-cultural-marxism/.
- Harold Marcuse, “Biographical Notes on Herbert Marcuse,” April 1997, accessed November 12, 2026, https://marcuse.faculty.history.ucsb.edu/herbert.htm.
- Herbert Marcuse, Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud (Beacon Press, 1955), 3.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 3, emphasis in original.
- Alisa Ruddell, “Sigmund Freud and the Making of Our Modern Sexual Identity,” Christian Research Journal 49, no. 1 (2026), https://www.equip.org/articles/sigmund-freud-and-the-making-of-our-modern-sexual-identity/.
- Sigmund Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents, trans. James Strachey (W. W. Norton, 1961).
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, chap. 10 and passim.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, chap. 2 and passim.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 44–45.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 84–85.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 84–85, emphasis in original.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 45–46.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 155–56.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 45–46.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 47–49.
- Karl Marx, “Critique of the Gotha Programme,” pt. 1, Marxists Internet Archive, accessed October 17, 2026, https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1875/gotha/ch01.htm.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 156.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 158.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 156–57, emphasis in original.
- Herbert Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society (Beacon Press, 1964), 188 and passim.
- Bernstein, “Herbert Marcuse: An Immanent Critique,” 109.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 97.
- Mark Featherstone, “Review: Aaron Bastani, ‘Fully Automated Luxury Communism: A Manifesto,’” Theory, Culture & Society, February 11, 2020, https://www.theoryculturesociety.org/blog/review-aaron-bastani-fully-automated-luxury-communism.
- Jean-Christophe Bélisle-Pipon, “AI, Universal Basic Income, and Power: Symbolic Violence in the Tech Elite’s Narrative,” Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence 8 (2025), https://doi.org/10.3389/frai.2025.1488457.
- Demis Hassibis quoted in Brent D. Griffiths, “A Future Without Work? What Elon Musk, Bill Gates, Sam Altman, and Others in AI Are Saying About the Future,” Business Insider, updated May 10, 2026, https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-ai-universal-high-income-ubi-2026-1.
- Jay W. Richards, “History’s Bloody Mess: Why Marxism (and Socialism) Always Fails,” Christian Research Journal 42, no. 01 (2019), https://www.equip.org/articles/historys-bloody-mess-why-marxism-and-socialism-always-fails/.
- Pope Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum, The Holy See: Encyclicals, May 15, 1891, https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_l-xiii_enc_15051891_rerum-novarum.html. Pope Leo XIV, Magnifica Humanitas: On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligence, The Holy See: Encyclicals, May 15, 2026, https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/encyclicals/documents/20260515-magnifica-humanitas.html.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 203.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 49–50.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 49–50.
- Marcuse, Eros and Civilization, 48–49.
- Ruddell, “Sigmund Freud and the Making of Our Modern Sexual Identity.”
- Herbert Marcuse, Chapter 3, “The Conquest of the Unhappy Consciousness: Repressive Desublimation,” in One-Dimensional Man.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 50, emphasis in original.
- Douglas Kellner, “Radical Politics, Marcuse, and the New Left,” in Collected Papers of Herbert Marcuse, vol. 3: The New Left and the 1960s, ed. and intro. Douglas Kellner (Routledge, 2005), 2, https://www.pages.gseis.ucla.edu/faculty/kellner/essays/newleftand1960s.pdf.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 1.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, xvi.
- For additional critiques of modern technological society, see the following: Lewis Mumford, Technics and Civilization (1934), Jacques Ellul, The Technological Society (1954), Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (1958), Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man (1964), Ivan Illich, Tools for Conviviality (1973).
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, xvi.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 3.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 10.
- Bernstein, “Herbert Marcuse: An Immanent Critique,” 97.
- Sarah Kuta, “Reading for Pleasure Has Declined by a ‘Deeply Concerning’ 40 Percent over the Past Two Decades,” Smithsonian Magazine, August 26, 2025, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/reading-for-pleasure-has-declined-by-a-deeply-concerning-40-percent-over-the-past-two-decades-180987228/.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 71.
- John Laidler, “High Tech Is Watching You,” Harvard Gazette, March 4, 2019, https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2019/03/harvard-professor-says-surveillance-capitalism-is-undermining-democracy/. “Surveillance capitalists now develop ‘economies of action,’ as they learn to tune, herd, and condition our behavior with subtle and subliminal cues, rewards, and punishments that shunt us toward their most profitable outcomes. What is abrogated here is our right to the future tense, which is the essence of free will, the idea that I can project myself into the future and thus make it a meaningful aspect of my present. This is the essence of autonomy and human agency. Surveillance capitalism’s ‘means of behavioral modification’ at scale erodes democracy from within because, without autonomy in action and in thought, we have little capacity for the moral judgment and critical thinking necessary for a democratic society.”
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 71.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 4–6 and passim.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 72.
- Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man, 256.
- MacIntyre, Herbert Marcuse: An Exposition and a Polemic, 102–3.
- Herbert Marcuse, “Repressive Tolerance,” in The Essential Marcuse: Selected Writings of Philosopher and Social Critic Herbert Marcuse, ed. Andrew Feenberg and William Leiss (Beacon Press, 2007), 41–42.
- Marcuse, “Repressive Tolerance,” 105.
- Marcuse, “Repressive Tolerance,” 50.
- Marcuse, “Repressive Tolerance,” 56–57.
- VICE News, “Campus Argument Goes Viral as Evergreen State Is Caught in Racial Turmoil,” YouTube, video 7:02, posted June 16, 2017, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cMYfxOFBBM.
- John Wood Jr., “The Beating of Andy Ngo,” Braver Angels, July 8, 2019, https://braverangels.org/the-beating-of-andy-ngo/.
- Arjun Mehta, “Antifa Violence Statistics,” Worldmetrics Report 2026, updated July 26, 2026, https://worldmetrics.org/antifa-violence-statistics/.
- Richard Fausset, “Here’s What Some of the Bullet Casing Engravings in the Charlie Kirk Shooting Mean,” The New York Times, September 12, 2026, https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/12/us/charlie-kirk-bullet-casings-engravings.html.
- Ezra Klein, “Charlie Kirk Was Practicing Politics the Right Way,” The New York Times, September 11, 2025, https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/11/opinion/charlie-kirk-assassination-fear-politics.html.
- Roxanne Gay, “Civility Is a Fantasy,” The New York Times, September 24, 2025, https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/24/opinion/civility-fantasy-power-kirk.html.
- Jared Downing, “One Third of College Students Say Using Violence to Shut Down Speech on Campus Is Acceptable: Poll,” New York Post, August 28, 2026, https://nypost.com/2026/08/28/us-news/third-of-college-students-say-its-ok-to-use-violence-to-shut-down-speech/.
- FIRE, “2026 College Free Speech Rankings: America’s Colleges Get an ‘F’ for Poor Free Speech Climate,” Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, September 9, 2025, https://www.fire.org/news/2026-college-free-speech-rankings-americas-colleges-get-f-poor-free-speech-climate.
- Neil Shenvi, “What Is the ‘Woke Right’?,” Shenvi Apologetics, accessed October 25, 2026, https://shenviapologetics.com/what-is-the-woke-right/.
- James Marriott, The New Dark Ages: The Death of Reading and the Dawn of the Post-Literate Society (Bodley Head, 2026).
- Pope Leo XIV, “Homily,” 30th Sunday in Ordinary Time, St. Peter’s Basilica, October 26, 2025, https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/homilies/2025/documents/20251026-giubileo-equipe-sinodali.html.
- Klein, “Charlie Kirk Was Practicing Politics the Right Way.”
- Acton Bell (Alisa Ruddell), “A Tale of Two Journalists: Charlie Kirk’s Murder and the American Debate About Civility,” Oompod, October 13, 2025, https://oompod.substack.com/p/a-tale-of-two-journalists.

